Having just written a post yesterday on civility in discussions of religion and non-belief, I was interested when I came across this article attacking biologist, and popular atheist blogger P.Z. Myers via Project Reason. Now I understand that Professor Myers is not afraid to say how he feels, so to speak, and therefore it is not so surprising that some people might, from time to time, get upset with him. I quite enjoy his writings, which I recommend you read if by some tiny chance you made it here before seeing his vastly more popular and established blog.
Anyhow, back to the article in question. I read through the piece which was one part ad hominem attack and one part tutorial in the inanities of intelligent design. I felt the need to say...something. But when I got to the comments thread it seems that someone had beaten me to the punch. More like someones. At last check there were 218 comments with the majority by far defending Professor Myers. I think there were only one or two that were in support of the article. Myers also replied on his blog.
Seriously, P.Z. Myers doesn't need me to publicize this. I just wanted to say that, even though I tend to be less vocal, I do so enjoy seeing an ID pusher get shredded whenever I can. Thank you secular internet.
Monday, May 30, 2011
Sunday, May 29, 2011
Should we play nice?
It seems that right now the question of how aggressively atheist we should be is floating around in many media outlets. The Guardian published this interview with Martin Rees (which incidentally ticked me off bad enough to start this blog, but that is a topic for another day). Perhaps it has something to do with the recent failed predictions of Harold Camping. That is the suggestion over at Skepticblog. Indeed, I myself have been pretty hard on Mr. Camping and his followers. They were pretty easy targets, and I still believe that they behaved in a foolhardy manner, but it is important to remember that they are people and that this whole experience has probably been a difficult and painful one for them. At the same time, how do you react to people who behave or believe so irrationally.
I tend to fall somewhere in the middle on the confrontation scale. I don't think it is necessary to go out of our way to poke fun at people with strange or unsubstantiated beliefs. People are allowed to think whatever they want. However, if someone challenges me on my non-belief or tries proselytizing to me, they should be prepared to defend their beliefs, because they voluntarily crossed that line. In cases like that I think that it is important for us to be quite vocal about why we are non-believers, and show that we are also normal human beings. Basically, we shouldn't hide who we are because we are afraid of a) being socially outcast or b) offending the overtly religious. I think that that is pretty straight forward. We are who we are, and we believe what we believe (or don't believe) and we shouldn't be ashamed of it.
It becomes a more difficult question, however, when we are dealing with someone who is not directly challenging us or trying to convert us, but is still speaking with an air of religious authority. It is like when someone at a party says something that is just blatantly wrong like "cockroaches are smarter than dogs" or "potato chips are really healthy" or "I think I am a little psychic" or "the Secret is such an awesome book". You feel bad correcting them, because you don't want to be that person, but you also feel the need to correct an obvious factual error. One that I encountered recently when talking about the economy was "Christ said, 'there will be poor always'." Do you let that go? Incidentally, rather than challenge the religious aspects of it, I challenged the statement on its own. Of course this conversation was with a family member whom I have a great deal of respect for. Would I have reacted differently if it had been someone whom I did not respect so much? I don't know. I can say though that I believe that we should pick our battles. Sometimes the offense is too great to let slide and we should challenge it, even at the risk of appearing rude. Other times, we should just let it slide.
How about mockery? I quite liked the attitude of Daniel Loxton's blog entry from Skepticblog (linked above). Really, how effective is mockery? Even if it works, it is kind of going over to the dark side, in that it is coercive and doesn't make people think critically. One exception that I could possibly see is when we are actually publicly debating someone or dealing with a powerful organization. In a debate if you can make your opponent look obviously foolish, without making yourself look like a bully or a jerk, it could help you win the debate. When dealing with powerful organizations that promote wrong ideas I am not really concerned about their feelings, and would like to be a part of decreasing the quality of their public images. Some examples include: Answers in Genesis (people living with dinosaurs), The Discovery Institute (intelligent design), the Thomas More Law Center (have a look), and many others. Still, I think belittling a person you are having a friendly conversation with, in almost all cases is a lose-lose idea.
I tend to fall somewhere in the middle on the confrontation scale. I don't think it is necessary to go out of our way to poke fun at people with strange or unsubstantiated beliefs. People are allowed to think whatever they want. However, if someone challenges me on my non-belief or tries proselytizing to me, they should be prepared to defend their beliefs, because they voluntarily crossed that line. In cases like that I think that it is important for us to be quite vocal about why we are non-believers, and show that we are also normal human beings. Basically, we shouldn't hide who we are because we are afraid of a) being socially outcast or b) offending the overtly religious. I think that that is pretty straight forward. We are who we are, and we believe what we believe (or don't believe) and we shouldn't be ashamed of it.
It becomes a more difficult question, however, when we are dealing with someone who is not directly challenging us or trying to convert us, but is still speaking with an air of religious authority. It is like when someone at a party says something that is just blatantly wrong like "cockroaches are smarter than dogs" or "potato chips are really healthy" or "I think I am a little psychic" or "the Secret is such an awesome book". You feel bad correcting them, because you don't want to be that person, but you also feel the need to correct an obvious factual error. One that I encountered recently when talking about the economy was "Christ said, 'there will be poor always'." Do you let that go? Incidentally, rather than challenge the religious aspects of it, I challenged the statement on its own. Of course this conversation was with a family member whom I have a great deal of respect for. Would I have reacted differently if it had been someone whom I did not respect so much? I don't know. I can say though that I believe that we should pick our battles. Sometimes the offense is too great to let slide and we should challenge it, even at the risk of appearing rude. Other times, we should just let it slide.
How about mockery? I quite liked the attitude of Daniel Loxton's blog entry from Skepticblog (linked above). Really, how effective is mockery? Even if it works, it is kind of going over to the dark side, in that it is coercive and doesn't make people think critically. One exception that I could possibly see is when we are actually publicly debating someone or dealing with a powerful organization. In a debate if you can make your opponent look obviously foolish, without making yourself look like a bully or a jerk, it could help you win the debate. When dealing with powerful organizations that promote wrong ideas I am not really concerned about their feelings, and would like to be a part of decreasing the quality of their public images. Some examples include: Answers in Genesis (people living with dinosaurs), The Discovery Institute (intelligent design), the Thomas More Law Center (have a look), and many others. Still, I think belittling a person you are having a friendly conversation with, in almost all cases is a lose-lose idea.
Tuesday, May 24, 2011
In for a penny...
Harold Camping. The Campmeister. El Camparino. Camper. I am starting to like this guy. Not because I think he is on to anything. No, I think he is pretty much out of his mind. But reading this article about his reaction to the Rapture fail, I have to say he is good value. Sticks to his guns and all that. It reminds me of the first Austin Powers movie when Austin hits on a 21 saying that he "too like(s) to live dangerously". So, the Rapture didn't happen, but the world is still going to end on October 21 of this year. Whatever you say, buddy. *wink* *wink*
Sadly, I doubt this one will get quite the media attention of the last one, but I can dream...
Sadly, I doubt this one will get quite the media attention of the last one, but I can dream...
Monday, May 23, 2011
Okay, faith and what else?
Today, for the second time in my career as an atheist, someone has presented me with the argument that they believe in god because of faith. I don't know why people think that this is a good argument. Correct me if I am wrong, but doesn't faith mean basically the same thing as belief? I know there are variations on the definitions of faith that give it some different shades of meaning, but essentially it is the same thing, right? If I told someone I believe something because I believe it, I am sure that I would be met with blank stares and derision, but if I replace the word "belief" with the word "faith", suddenly it becomes an argument.
I find this argument especially annoying because everyone has faith is something or someone, but we do it because there are reasons that we have that faith. I am not talking about anything supernatural. I am talking about things like faith that friends care for you and family members love you. Maybe it is all a lie, but I have reason to believe it is not. Sometimes the reasons for faith end up not being reliable, but they are there. I am sure it is the same for religious peoples' faith. Has it been instilled in you from childhood? Are you afraid of god's wrath? Is it the sense of community you feel in church? Do you believe the Bible is the literal word of god? Is it a feeling you get when you are alone? Does god talk to you? Have you been visited by angels? You are not likely to convince me, but at least we can have an adult conversation about it. So if you are religious and you insist on talking to me about religion please tell me the reason that you have faith, not simply that you do! The thing worries me is that people might not know why they have this faith, and they are unwilling to really think about it.
I find this argument especially annoying because everyone has faith is something or someone, but we do it because there are reasons that we have that faith. I am not talking about anything supernatural. I am talking about things like faith that friends care for you and family members love you. Maybe it is all a lie, but I have reason to believe it is not. Sometimes the reasons for faith end up not being reliable, but they are there. I am sure it is the same for religious peoples' faith. Has it been instilled in you from childhood? Are you afraid of god's wrath? Is it the sense of community you feel in church? Do you believe the Bible is the literal word of god? Is it a feeling you get when you are alone? Does god talk to you? Have you been visited by angels? You are not likely to convince me, but at least we can have an adult conversation about it. So if you are religious and you insist on talking to me about religion please tell me the reason that you have faith, not simply that you do! The thing worries me is that people might not know why they have this faith, and they are unwilling to really think about it.
Sunday, May 22, 2011
A spot of tea
In my recent rage over current politics in the U.S. I decided to take a look at how the other half live, so to speak. This landed me over at the home page of Tea Party Patriots. I was immediately struck by the banner that reads "TEACH U.S. HISTORY IN OUR SCHOOLS". Ignoring the conundrum of a group who thinks that teachers are making too much money demanding more education, I remembered that I did indeed study U.S. history in school. Have schools in the U.S. stopped doing this? I had to know more. So I went here. I found the campaign interesting in that it not only asked its readers to send a letter to their school superintendent, but it asked for them to send three letters, and they want you to send letters that they (Tea Party Patriots) have written. Hmm. What was their angle here (Sharon?)? At the bottom of the text I noticed there is a link to the NCCS store which sells a "Constitution Week Education Package". NCCS, huh? NCCS stands for National Center for Constitutional studies. Fair enough, I think it is important for us to study the Constitution. Wait, was the NCCS the same group that published The Making of America by Cleon Skousen, which claimed that "white slave owners were the worst victims" of slavery? I'll spare you the suspense; it was. Is that the U.S. history that they want taught in schools? Anyhow, if you have some time to spare you can go over to NCCS site and test your knowledge of history with one of their super fun quizzes. See if you can spot the agenda.
#$%@&$#@#!!!
Now that we know that the destruction of the world is not imminent, I feel it is safe to talk about more serious topics. Right now there is no subject more guaranteed to raise my blood pressure than the all-out assault that the right is carrying out on the middle class in America. I know times are tough and the money to run everything has to come from somewhere, but why are we taking it away from the people who educate our children? And why must we take away unions' collective bargaining as well? What does that have to do with anything? Why aren't we taking the money from the irresponsible villians (that is the nicest way I feel I can describe them) who caused the world economy to nearly collapse on the first place? It literally boggles my mind to think of how anyone can vote republican unless they make over $250,000 a year. They are the only ones being served by this. The rest of the base must be held hostage by social issues, which most of the time do not even concern them (e.g. gay marriage). That is the only explanation that I can think of that makes any sense at all. A few years ago a coworker complained to me that the United States was turning into a third world country. At the time I thought he was nuts, and I told him so. Now, he may be right.
Anyhow, I am a bit out of my depth talking about economics, but I read this article from Vanity Fair, and I recommend you read it too. Chilling.
Anyhow, I am a bit out of my depth talking about economics, but I read this article from Vanity Fair, and I recommend you read it too. Chilling.
Saturday, May 21, 2011
Still here
Well, looks like the Rapture didn't happen. I am glad I decided not to sell all of my personal belongings, and quit my job. I hope that for the people that did, this has served as a powerful lesson. Sadly, however, even though this "guaranteed" prophecy has completely, and utterly failed, I doubt many of the true believers will be shaken in their faith. Oh well. I will take a victory for reason, even if it is a tiny one. It was a good party, regardless.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)